A disturbing number of people seem obsessed with
obesity, saying
things are just getting worse and worse, and that our kids are all
getting fatter and fatter. In the US, this idea seems particularly
prevalent in baby boomers living around LA, though it continues to be
adopted by too many people globally and in every generation. It’s an
excuse for telling other people how to run their lives, after all, and
that sort of thing is never unpopular.
More disturbing is that ani-obesity is also
the AMA party line. Remember, for every person who is obese and
has serious medical problems as a result, there are plenty who don’t.
This notion that obesity is getting worse this seems strange to me.
I’m in my late 30s, and seen a generation or three. Each one seemed
less obese and more fit to me. The
most obese of all, of course, was the one that’s voiced the most
intolance and grumbles the most about obese kids.
When I was a kid, my friends and I didn’t work out or get all much
exercise compared to today. Very few tummies were taut. There were
exercise programs, but they were ill-considered; the running program
was so severe few could handle it. Plus, I and many other kids had
limited activities because of asthma problems we now have good, cheap
drugs for.
The first stage was broad exercise programs that really work. That’s
huge. I see plenty of non-thin kids, but few with flabby tummies.
And I think it’s staying fit that’s the big difference-maker for
health, more than not weighing much or being fashionably thin.
Today, I’m seeing a higher and higher percentage of kids clearly into
serious exercise, and seriously muscled in a way that was very rare
when I was a kid.
There is a some widely-circulated evidence that obesity
is getting worse. The statement is that obesity levels are higher
today than in the ’70s. But the test they use to decide who’s
obese has changed rather decidedly since then. Therefore, this
fails as evidence. It disturbs me that big groups like the WHO,
who have tons of evidentially trained people, have failed to notice
that detail.
Oh, and let’s face it, the evidence that HFCS is contributing
noticeably to obesity isn’t even close to there yet. You need to
show actual results, not just potential mechanisms. Me? Yeah, I hate
HFCS, too, but let’s be honest on what this is about. Most HFCS
hatred is actually because we wish for better, oh yeah, better cookies
and soda. That’ll help reduce obesity so much. Hmm. And the
correct target of that hatred should be Congress and ADM, for
subsidizing corn and lobbying for the subsidies, respectively. Note
that Congress, unlike greed, can be lobbied (tell ‘em you want your
sugar cookies made of sugar!).
Appropriate societal action on obesity is to warn people of the
medical dangers, especially people with conditions truly statistically
linked to obesity (not just by fashion). Action and statements beyond
that amount to intolerance just as bad as any other kind that falls
short of shooting people.
And I have a message for all those anti-obese out there. I accuse you
of having fun telling all us fatties how bad we are. You know
that’s not allowed!
Disclaimer: I’m very nearly obese under official standards, since I have
a stocky frame, and spend alot of time biking.